When to Copy India's Aggressive Field Settings | Cricket coaching, fitness and tips

When to Copy India's Aggressive Field Settings

In a low scoring one day game, India's stand-in captain Virat Kohli, was unusually aggressive with his field settings. Is this a method you should copy?

There are certainly times when a bit of creative thinking results in unexpected fields, and results that hail you as a brilliant tactical leader.

But you need to be careful as a captain or bowler.

Limited over games are essentially about restricting the run rate. Wickets are important in doing this, so attacking is one way of slowing the rate. It's also a way of leaving gaps that batter can exploit, so you are constantly aware of the risks.

Many captains and bowlers play safe. The goes back as soon as possible and the focus is on slowing the rate with accurate bowling and reducing boundaries.

This is a legitimate tactic, even though it is often called uncreative.

Bolder captains hang on for longer. The slip stays in place for an extra over. 6 stay in the circle even after a couple of boundaries. It is aggressive and looking to take wickets. When it works you get praise because a wicket can easily turn a game in a handful of balls.

But leave the field up for too long and you look foolish. You become accused of being tactically naive; especially when you field second.

Where to draw the line

Different people will tell you different things about when to attack and when to defend. However a simple rule of thumb is to ask yourself a simple question; how badly do I need a wicket?

In almost any game situation you need a wicket, but if the opposition need 12 an over and are 8 down, you don't need one very much. On the other hand, if they are ahead of the chasing rate you need one rather urgently.

It stands to reason you would look to try and take a wicket with a field setting more urgently in the latter case. This was true for Kohli in the ODI. He knew the score of 229 would be impossible to defend unless he bowled the West Indies out. So he tried to take wickets.

And that is where you can draw the line too.

It's very easy to set the field back as soon as you feel you are losing momentum. In fact it makes more sense to have more up (or even in close) to turn the game around. Wickets do that faster than any other way.

Keeping control

That said, it's also easy to be mindless with your attacking field. If you set a ring field and the batsmen are blazing it around then it's time to come up with another plan. Wickets don't just come from the catchers and in-fielders.

You still need to balance the run rate with the chance of tacking a wicket. The key is that the greater your need, the more attacking you can be.

Sometimes you will decide that the orthodox one day field will get the job done. It often does. But make sure that, like Kohli, you are thinking through your reasons and deciding how best to allocate your fielders.

That way when you walk off the field you can hold your head high in the face of critics whether you were right or wrong.

Broadcast Your Cricket Matches!

Ever wanted your skills to be shown to the world? PV/MATCH is the revolutionary product for cricket clubs and schools to stream matches, upload HD highlights instantly to Twitter and Facebook and make you a hero!

PV/MATCH let's you score the game, record video of each ball, share it and use the outcomes to take to training and improve you further.

Click here for details.


You also need to consider how the change of field setting will affect the batsman's mindset. Sometimes if you very visibly start to attack him, instead of taking advantage of the open spaces, he suddenly becomes aware of his own mortality and starts to play more defensively.

The same applies the other way round, if you're trying to force a win and want a batsmen to stop blocking and hit out, perhaps put a few men back to make him feel like he is "on top". Crazier things have happened.

I have never tried the second strategy, but I guess it makes senses as an extension of the idea of putting the slow, loopy spinner on to tempt the tail-ender.

Its certainly a fascinating topic - the juxtaposition of orthodox field setting concepts with psychology and game theory.