Pietersen's Chin, Ronaldo's Feet and the Wide Stance 8 Year Old | Cricket coaching, fitness and tips

Pietersen's Chin, Ronaldo's Feet and the Wide Stance 8 Year Old

You are the coach. What do you do?

An 8 year old walks into a junior session for the first time and gets into a batting stance with his feet wide apart and his knees flexed.

There is a temptation to adjust the stance into a more conventional narrower stance as seen in MCC manuals from years gone by.

But is that right?

I know that I have done exactly that in the past, but ask yourself the question: Why does that player stand like that?

There is a good chance that the player finds his wider stance more comfortable, natural and balanced giving him a position to spring out and whack the ball with power!

So is it right for us to take these attributes away from the batter when it feels like the natural thing for him to do?

Good coaches observe; great coaches notice

So what do we notice in a natural young talent who prefers a wider stance with flexed knees?

Firstly, that the heels have a strong contact with the ground.

Players like this tend to "push off from the ground" rather than "lean into" shots using their head and front shoulder. Most manuals, and most coaches, encourage everyone to do the latter.

But some people initiate movement differently to the ball.

Secondly, you may notice that players like this hit with their chin up at point of contact rather than the conventional chin down (with top of the head on view to the bowler from the front).

"Chin up" players have a lower visual field (naturally angled down towards the ground) and therefore, do not need to dip their head to keep their eye on the ball coming into contact.

Incidentally, this is the complete opposite to my visual field where I need to play with my chin down in order to see the ball come into contact whether I'm catching or hitting.

Where is the evidence?

It's the same across all sports. In soccer Ronaldo and Messi lead with their head with the ball at their feet. Tevez and Beckham push off from the ground

What differences do you notice with their head positions when in control of the ball?

Which direction are their eyes appearing to look in?

I know what you are saying.

"I want cricket proof, Garas."

Look at this picture of Kevin Pietersen driving the ball off of the front foot (taken from Keep Calm and Smash It):

Then compare his head position and direction of his eyes with the point of contact positions of Andrew Strauss or Ricky Ponting.

what differences do you notice?

What stances do the two pairs of batters take prior to ball release?

KP has a wide base with flexed knees and pushes off to move. His chin is up at contact.

Straussy and Punter have narrower stances, less flexion in their knees and lean into the ball to move with the chin down at contact.

So, here is the 8 year old standing in his natural stance.

What do you do now?

Broadcast Your Cricket Matches!

Ever wanted your skills to be shown to the world? PV/MATCH is the revolutionary product for cricket clubs and schools to stream matches, upload HD highlights instantly to Twitter and Facebook and make you a hero!

PV/MATCH let's you score the game, record video of each ball, share it and use the outcomes to take to training and improve you further.

Click here for details.


hi david i have a question for you.Since there is a lot of debate going about open stance and closed stance i have to inquire about the open stance batting position.does open stance means that you have to move your shoulders and feet slightly pointing to the mid on.in this way both feet will not be parallel to the creased but slightly turned in like this

| \
| \
here straight line is the crease and the other one is feet position turned slightly
.kindly reply

That is correct ussama.

As a left eyed, left handed batsman, I always stand with my back foot pointing at point and my front foot opened slightly to point at cover. Its the only way you can really get your head absolutely straight on and watch the ball with both eyes.

It also feels more natural stepping forward with my toe already pointing partially in that direction. If you were going to take a step forward you wouldn't start with your feet side on would you?

My son is 14 now and a left eyed, right handed batsman. Bowls left handed and rights left handed.

What would be his best stance.

Any one with advise ?

Make sure the head is aligned bang over middle stump, completely upright with the eyes leve, and turned round to look straight up the pitch at the bowler. If that means opening up the front shoulder and hip slightly, that is fine.

Would you leave the batsman's stance alone and see how he goes?

In answer to your question as to what to do with the 8 year old - let him play, if he is striking the ball well and appears comfortable, leave the stance as it is. If not striking the ball well, try to pinpoint why (not necessarily the stance!).

My feelings about the stance is that as long as the batsman is comfortable, is looking at the bowler with eyes level, and is striking the ball well, why change anything?

Would Chanderpaul have become the player he is today if he had had an over-eager coach tinkering with his stance? Maybe, maybe not - but the fact is he didn't and he still became one of the modern day test greats...